Design Observer

About
Books
Job Board
Newsletters
Archive
Contact



Observatory

About
Resources
Submissions
Contact


Featured Writers

Michael Bierut
William Drenttel
John Foster
Jessica Helfand
Alexandra Lange
Mark Lamster
Paul Polak
Rick Poynor
John Thackara
Rob Walker


Departments

Advertisement
Audio
Books
Collections
Dear Bonnie
Dialogues
Essays
Events
Foster Column
From Our Archive
Gallery
Interviews
Miscellaneous
Opinions
Partner News
Photos
Poetry
Primary Sources
Projects
Report
Reviews
Slideshows
The Academy
Today Column
Unusual Suspects
Video


Topics

Advertising
Architecture
Art
Books
Branding
Business
Cities / Places
Community
Craft
Culture
Design History
Design Practice
Development
Disaster Relief
Ecology
Economy
Education
Energy
Environment
Fashion
Film / Video
Food/Agriculture
Geography
Global / Local
Graphic Design
Health / Safety
History
Housing
Ideas
Illustration
India
Industry
Info Design
Infrastructure
Interaction Design
Internet / Blogs
Journalism
Landscape
Literature
Magazines
Media
Museums
Music
Nature
Obituary
Other
Peace
Philanthropy
Photography
Planning
Poetry
Politics / Policy
Popular Culture
Poverty
Preservation
Product Design
Public / Private
Public Art
Religion
Reputations
Science
Shelter
Social Enterprise
Sports
Sustainability
Technology
Theory/Criticism
Transportation
TV / Radio
Typography
Urbanism
Water


Comments (23) Posted 09.13.09 | PERMALINK | PRINT

John Cantwell

The Big Screen in Big D


The centerpiece of Cowboys Stadium, Arlington, Texas. Photo by AP Photo/Tony Gutierrez

There are many exciting moments in your typical NFL game. A running back, disregarding all self-preservational instinct, leaps headfirst over a pile of linemen and lands in the end zone. A linebacker nearly decapitates some rail-thin wide receiver flashing across the middle. Cheerleaders return from halftime wearing new outfits. A punt, however, does not generally quicken one’s pulse. Punts are the prelude to a commercial break, a moment to pause and consider that next beer, or to wonder if it’s worth bathing today.

So when A.J. Trapasso, the Tennessee Titans’ backup punter, stepped onto the field during a sleepy preseason game in Dallas this August, it’s likely that nobody was expecting anything out of the ordinary. In fact, there were probably very few eyes on Trapasso when the football boomed off his foot. That’s because Trapasso was kicking in the Dallas Cowboys’ bombastic new $1.2 billion stadium, an ultra-opulent temple built to honor owner Jerry Jones’s great loves — football, the Cowboys, and conspicuous consumption. The fans in attendance were probably looking at anything besides the punt — the “world’s largest operable glass doors,” for instance, which can be found at the far end of the stadium, and through which the entire field slides on a set of tracks when non-football events are held at the stadium.

Even more likely, they were gawking at a very, very large scoreboard — the 160-foot-long, 1.2 million pound, Mitsubishi Diamond Vision true HD display, that is the centerpiece of Cowboys Stadium. This is a spectacular object, this scoreboard. It cost, by itself, twice as much to build as the previous Cowboys Stadium. It is maintained via a ten-level internal scaffolding system and its use requires the services of a full-time, highly trained operations team. Its display capacity is equal to 4,920 52-inch flat panel televisions, and it is illuminated by 30 million pulsing light bulbs. In short, it makes your typical Jumbotron look like a 13-inch TV/VCR.

But the devil, as they say, is in the details. As Trapasso’s otherwise ordinary kick neared its apex, the ball ricocheted off the bottom of the screen and dropped to the turf like a duck shot from the sky. That was not supposed to happen.

Someone hung the damn scoreboard too low.

Confusion took hold that evening in Dallas. Titans coach Jeff Fisher challenged the play, claiming interference, and the referees kind of shrugged their shoulders, not exactly sure how to proceed. You see, there is little precedent for such events in the NFL rulebook, mostly because no team had ever constructed a scoreboard the size of Rhode Island.
How, you might ask, could such a colossal oversight come to pass? How could someone install a $40 million scoreboard and not take into consideration the fact that games are played beneath it? Was it hubris? Incompetence? An honest mistake? These questions are irrelevant. The NFL ruled afterwards that the Cowboys do not have to raise the scoreboard until the season has ended. For this one season, games played in Dallas will be some weird mashup of football and pinball. And believe it or not, this is a good thing.

To understand why, you must understand the spirit of the NFL, which is cold and steely, like a refrigerator door. In the NFL, unregimented behavior, peculiar attitudes — these things are frowned upon. Players wearing the wrong-colored cleats are fined heavily. Acts of self-expression are strongly discouraged: in order for Bengals wide receiver Chad “Ochocinco” Johnson to wear his nickname on the back of his jersey, he was forced to legally change his last name to…Ochocinco. Unlike baseball, with its pastoral traditions and idiosyncratic ballparks, professional football is a game of stark uniformity. This is manifested most significantly in the design of NFL stadiums. Giants Stadium, the Superdome, the old Astrodome, and even the newer stadiums in Philadelphia and Baltimore — all massive, soulless, interchangeable bowls, possessing no distinct visual identity. Of course, this is no accident. Football, America’s great and mighty game, is played in these stadiums. If you want bells and whistles, go ride a Schwinn.

But now…now there is this massive, wonderful, ill-conceived scoreboard in Dallas, looming over the field like the Death Star, deflecting punts and infuriating coaches and giving you, the viewer at home, something new and innocuous to get excited about. “Look at that stupid thing,” you’ll say. “It’s too damn big! Those guys in Dallas, they’re idiots.”
But you won’t be changing the channel during a punt.
|
Share This Story

Comments (23)   |   JUMP TO MOST RECENT COMMENT >>

I thought there was only one "D" and that is Detroit? As far as music and pop culture are concerned Detroit is "the D". Even people across continents call Detroit, "the D".

Kevin in Cusco
09.14.09 at 09:21

"If you want bells and whistles, go ride a Schwinn."
Schwinn went belly up in 2001.

btw- I used to live at the end of Jerry Jones Street in Big D's Turtle Creek. What a pathetic, womanizing loser. RIP: Tom Landry.
Felix sockwell
09.14.09 at 10:02

I have seen a game at the stadium and the detail on the large screen is amazing. However, if you are sitting on the side of the field with the cameras, the offensive team moves (for example) from right to left on both the field and the screen. BUT on the opposite side of the stadium the screen shows the offense moving right to left, where on the field they are moving left to right. This is not exactly a deal breaker for the fans, but it does take some adjustment. The stadium is nice and while I do not approve of all of JJ's antics, he did hit a home run (hmmmm, that is a baseball metaphor, right?) with the stadium.
Fort Worth Guy
09.14.09 at 11:16

One more thing, and this is easy to miss if you are not "from here"...but the stadium is not in Big D....in fact it is not even in Dallas county. It is in Arlington, Texas which is in neighboring Tarrant County. FYI, Texas Stadium, the venue that the Cowboys just abandoned was also not in Dallas, it was in Irving.

No more, I promise.
Fort Worth Guy
09.14.09 at 11:55

I thought there was only one "D" and that is Detroit?

I just spent a week in Dallas and Fort Worth. Believe me, down there they think there is only one "Big D" and it ain't Detroit, partner.
Michael Bierut
09.14.09 at 12:05

Found the video online for those who missed it:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fjx6vsR71sg
web page designer
09.14.09 at 02:57

Coming from a New Yorker, I've never heard anything other than Dallas referred to as "The Big D." I definitely have never heard Detroit called "the D." On the other hand, if you say "the s---box that makes Cleveland look like Prague," then I know you're referring to Detroit.
Craig Lowell
09.14.09 at 04:07

And I have to give Cantwell props for his point of view on the scoreboard and the benefit it brings to the game. Jerry Jones is undoubtedly a jackass, but John's right that he's managed to make punts infinitely more entertaining.
Craig Lowell
09.14.09 at 04:08

And I have to give Cantwell props for his point of view on the scoreboard and the benefit it brings to the game. Jerry Jones is
شات
09.15.09 at 04:56

Your article is mis leading and poorly written. You obviously didn't do a tad wee bit amount of research before you wrote this god awful blog. The fact is Jerry Jones put the score board where it is for a reason. The reason for ever fan in the stadium to be able to have a perfect view of the monstrosity. Jerry Jones said its my stadium, I will put it in the best place for the fans. If people have to punt differently then so be it.

Your article is typical of a blogger or writer that has no real world experience or a quest to research the facts or the reasons behind a statement or action. Your only response is to jump to an un-educated conlusion.
PaidPiper
09.15.09 at 02:34

thank you for the feedback, paidpiper.

you are correct. this post is "god awful." i thought it was good, and the editors of this site obviously must have too, but you have proven us all wrong.

you'll be pleased to know that, as of right now, i am quitting writing. and it's because of you, and your excellent comment. many thanks for shaking me of my delusions. you are like the world's best guidance counselor.

humbled,

john cantwell
john cantwell
09.15.09 at 03:24

Thanks Michael Beirut.

Not really missing either of them. The accent nor the blowing trash.

Saludos from Peru.
Kevin in Cusco
09.15.09 at 06:48

I'm very pleased to see Design Observer spreading its wings a little bit and looking at all forms of popular culture including sports and how it relates to design. Too often this site becomes stale and takes itself a bit too seriously with some of the subject matter. This step towards design diversity is a good one and I'd love to see more of it.

That being said I feel that the author missed an important element of the current conversation. Both sides agree there is a problem with the placement of the scoreboard. Neither side wants to pay the million plus dollars to fix it. This is a classic scenario of guidelines being followed and then the discovery of problems with those guidelines as innovative solutions were implemented. Seems like a common design/client problem to me.

I gotta disagree with you when you say the NFL is stark and uniform. Players celebrate routine plays in the NFL more often than any other professional sport. Every tackle, dropped or made pass gets a mini celebration. If you celebrated that much in the NBA or MLB you'd have 12 hour games.
Chris
09.16.09 at 02:42

I think that one needs to take a step back and look at the scoreboard/giant television itself. Why would one go to a live game to watch it on a television???

I just finished reading Daniel Borstein's "The Image: A guide to Pseudo-Events in America" and this is exactly the kind of thing he outlines. (a brief explanation of a pseudo-event is something that is contrived, planned for or otherwise non-spontaneous) We have a football game going on right in front of us and yet most people will spend the time at the game watching the television.

We don't experience "the real" anymore. And designers (for the most part) are allowing our skill and ability to be used by those who seek to perpetuate the pattern of the creation of deceptive pseudo-events.

The problems with the scoreboard getting in the way aside, this is just another example of how we are being disconnected the more we are connected and allowing ourselves to be deceived -- no, asking and demanding that we be deceived.

Go read the book. If you disagree that the very implementation of this billboard constitutes a pseudo-event, then we need to talk.

iconiqdesigner
09.17.09 at 02:19

inconiqdesigner,

many thanks for your comment. you are right to bring up the idea of "pseudo-events" and there are, indeed, a few valid questions that this post never addresses. Such as:

- is such a large screen necessary, at all
- what are the implications of having such a large screen at a live sporting event?

it is definitely curious that jerry jones, the cowboys' owner, would spend so much on a lavish arena for fans to watch live football and then make the centerpiece of the stadium a television screen. in some ways, it seems as though he has simply created the most expensive place possible for cowboys fans to watch television. in this regard, the new stadium seems almost like a product of a recently bygone era. back in 2006, before the markets crashed, we might not have questioned - and maybe would have applauded - such an ostentatious feature. but now it seems kind of silly.

but, still, there are other factors to consider. for one, the new cowboys stadium does not only host football games. it is the site of concerts and, eventually, college basketball games. with this knowledge in mind, the giant screen makes much more sense. if i'm a rock fan living in the dallas area, i'm much more enthused about seeing a future U2 concert at the new stadium knowing this scoreboard is there, because it will provide me with views that no other large stadium offers. same goes for a college basketball fan sitting in the last row of the upper deck for a final four game.

and there are still other potential applications for the scoreboard that have not been tested. imagine going to see the latest hollywood blockbuster at cowboys stadium, with 80,000 other people. there would be a certain excitement to that, for sure.

this essay did not allude to these facts because i was particularly interested in how the new scoreboard would affect the games and how the scoreboard related to the general typology of nfl stadiums. nevertheless, the questions that a scoreboard of this size raises are certainly worth considering in our present time, and are likely to grow more pressing in the years ahead.
john cantwell
09.17.09 at 10:52

this games I think more tecnical is so need
links of london necklaces
09.18.09 at 03:37

detroit is surely the only "D" that i've ever heard of, and speaking of which, have you ever been to ford field? while the lions aren't worth checking out, the stadium is, and its hardly a cookie cutter affair. part of it is a reused Hudson's (department store) warehouse.
gravitymachine
09.18.09 at 11:24

Just saw on CNN that the screen it placed properly, being 5 feet above minimum hight (according to current NFL regulation) - that being the case, this article would indeed be a bit off???
Holly
09.18.09 at 11:41

holly,

you're right - the screen was hung above the minimum required height. the problem, though, is the screen's length. a shorter scoreboard hung at the same height would almost certainly not interfere with play. but because the scoreboard is 160 feet long, it needs to be hung higher in order to avoid the trajectory of punted balls.
john cantwell
09.18.09 at 12:47

@ iconiqdesigner

That screen, and jumbo screens at sports events serve a very important purpose for fans at a game. It enhances the experience. It gives people in the nosebleeds a chance to be fully engrossed in the game. This stadium holds over 100 thousand people. There is no seat in that house good enough to see game details. If anything this screen enhances the live experience by bringing in the best elements of staying home to watch it on HD television, combined with the atmosphere of a real game. This is the ultimate sports fanatic's dream experience.

No fan has a good enough seat to see a close play, or read the number on the jersey of that player who just made the great play. No one has the ability to turn back time and see an instant replay on their own. Those scoreboards enhance the experience. They will come in very valuable during the playoff push as fans want to know what's going on with the games being played by division rivals. Professional sports are entertainment meets spectacle.

Conceptually this scoreboard is completely appropriate for where it is installed. Its in Dallas, Texas where everything is bigger, for a franchise that has been calling itself "America's Team" for over 30 years. To have anything less self indulgent would be a design failure.

Chris
09.18.09 at 12:54

Easy jabs at football. Doing NASCAR next?
wata
09.19.09 at 03:31

@john - No basketball games will be played there, as that is what American Airlines center is for! :) Not only does Dallas have an ostentatious, over-the-top stadium, they have TWO.

@Chris - not only was it "America's Team," it was also "God's favorite team" (hence the hole in the top of Texas Stadium, the Cowboys' former home, so God could watch them play. Unfortunately for God, Jerry Jones has cancelled His season tickets.)

As a former Dallasite, I loved this article - it made me laugh out loud, knowing that often, we live up to our stereotypes.
andrea
10.16.09 at 01:59

Your blog is so informative … ..I just bookmarked you....keep up the good work!!!!
SaleHoo
01.05.10 at 11:10


Design Observer encourages comments to be short and to the point; as a general rule, they should not run longer than the original post. Comments should show a courteous regard for the presence of other voices in the discussion. We reserve the right to edit or delete comments that do not adhere to this standard.
Read Complete Comments Policy >>


Name             

Email address 




Please type the text shown in the graphic.


|
Share This Story



ABOUT THE AUTHOR

John Cantwell is a graduate of the College of the Holy Cross. He has worked as a research analyst, a freelance writer, and a standup comedian. He is currently enrolled in the inaugural class of the School of Visual Arts' Design Criticism MFA program.
More Bio >>

DESIGN OBSERVER JOBS









MORE BY John Cantwell

05.07.09: Trump, The Logo
More by John Cantwell >>

RELATED POSTS


Lucia Eames, 1930-2014
An appreciation of Lucia Eames (1930-2014).

The Astrodome and the Challenges of Preservation
The Astrodome and the future of preservation.

Not Afraid of Noise: Mexico City Stories
A photographic tour of Mexico City, house by house, wall by wall.

Genzken and the City
A review of Isa Genzken's current retrospective on view at the MOMA.

Premature Demolition
The Folk Art Museum, David Adjaye's market hall, and the first addition to the Morgan Library. If three makes a trend, then premature demolition qualifies.