Design Observer

About
Books
Job Board
Newsletters
Archive
Contact



Observatory

About
Resources
Submissions
Contact


Featured Writers

Michael Bierut
William Drenttel
John Foster
Jessica Helfand
Alexandra Lange
Mark Lamster
Paul Polak
Rick Poynor
John Thackara
Rob Walker


Departments

Advertisement
Audio
Books
Collections
Dear Bonnie
Dialogues
Essays
Events
Foster Column
From Our Archive
Gallery
Interviews
Miscellaneous
New Ideas
Opinions
Partner News
Photos
Poetry
Primary Sources
Projects
Report
Reviews
Slideshows
The Academy
Today Column
Unusual Suspects
Video


Topics

Advertising
Architecture
Art
Books
Branding
Business
Cities / Places
Community
Craft
Culture
Design History
Design Practice
Development
Disaster Relief
Ecology
Economy
Education
Energy
Environment
Fashion
Film / Video
Food/Agriculture
Geography
Global / Local
Graphic Design
Health / Safety
History
Housing
Ideas
Illustration
India
Industry
Info Design
Infrastructure
Interaction Design
Internet / Blogs
Journalism
Landscape
Literature
Magazines
Media
Museums
Music
Nature
Obituary
Other
Peace
Philanthropy
Photography
Planning
Poetry
Politics / Policy
Popular Culture
Poverty
Preservation
Product Design
Public / Private
Public Art
Religion
Reputations
Science
Shelter
Social Enterprise
Sports
Sustainability
Technology
Theory/Criticism
Transportation
TV / Radio
Typography
Urbanism
Water


Comments (20) Posted 03.16.09 | PERMALINK | PRINT

Mimi Lipson

A Place For Ribs



Broad Street Diner, January 16, 2009, photo by Mimi Lipson

I love/hate the Broad Street Diner. It may be the worst diner in Philadelphia, but I live practically across the street. When I first moved here, I was excited about having a 24-hour diner on my block. I imagined Saturday morning pancakes, a convenient bowl of soup, late night snacks on my way home from louche outings. I imagined showing the place off to envious houseguests who didn’t have 24-hour diners on their blocks. Boy, did I ever have a lot to learn.       

It looks pretty inviting from the outside. It has an attractive white brick-face façade with stainless steel trim. Mid-century. I come from a place where diners are tiny things, sometimes in old train cars. Stools and a counter, maybe a booth or two, somewhere to hang up your jacket. But around here the diners are grand, with picture windows and acres of terrazzo and “Bakery on Premises,” sometimes even cocktails. The Broad Street Diner is — or rather, once was — that type of place.

Out front, a towering sign:


BROAD STREET DINER 
Banquet Rooms 
A Place For Ribs


Look at what's going on in the parking lot and you start to get a feel for the place. There's always an attendant on duty…either the fat, ruddy halfwit or the skinny, bug-eyed freak. Most of the time I really don't know what they're doing. The skinny guy will sometimes open up the fire hydrant on the curb and flood my street, sending a river of trash down the block where it eventually comes to rest in damp, stinking piles.

Step inside. The dining room is big enough to accommodate two horseshoe-shaped counters, side by side (ostensibly Smoking and Nonsmoking, though the whole place is usually enveloped in a fog bank of smoke). There are two rows of booths to your right, one row to your left. There's an IN door and an OUT door, and to leave you have to pass through a turnstile and past the cashier, who sits reading the paper in a bulletproof enclosure.

Forget about American Graffiti or even Alice, because any charm the place may have once had has been stamped out by various desultory attempts at redecoration. The booths are covered in '80s vintage Burger King vinyl. There are plastic philodendrons in hanging baskets, and the ceiling is covered with white Formica. Two neon signs flicker and buzz on the far wall, one red and the other blue, spelling out — identically, redundantly — “Broad Street Diner” in airport bar cursive. Someone thought that was a good idea.

It smells like…like something septic beneath something antiseptic. And of course like cigarette smoke.

Above the counters, where you might see daily specials in some other diner, are photographs of food. Like in a ghetto Chinese takeout joint, but instead of pork lo mein and kung pao shrimp and fried rice with lobster sauce it’s meatloaf, spaghetti, chicken croquettes. I love pictures of food. One day I noticed that someone had taken down the pictures over the Smoking counter, so I asked the manager about it. I said I wanted them if they were getting thrown out anyway. He grudgingly took my phone number and shoved it behind the cash register. That was over a year ago. Nothing has been put up in their place, and the photos over the Nonsmoking counter are still there.


Desert menu at the Broad Street Diner

What I really covet, though, is the illuminated dessert menu in the vestibule. It’s a grid of photos on a florescent light box: various colorful parfaits and cakes and such, and then…momentarily unrecognizable beneath a ghostly nimbus of scuff-marks…sitting upright on a plate, its red flesh faded to orange…a half-slice of watermelon!

The food at the diner is an abomination, unless you stick to the Hamburger Alley section of the menu. Otherwise, beware: anything called a platter or a meal will arrive bobbing in a pool of sweet, glutinous gravy. No amount of cajoling, no specious claims of allergies will prevent them from putting mayonnaise on your grilled cheese sandwich. The fries have some sort of acrid flavor dust on them. You would think they couldn't fuck up breakfast — after all, it is a diner — but the eggs taste like rancid margarine and the potatoes are almost raw. Even the oatmeal is sticky, cold, congealed, and the less said about the coffee the better.       

I wonder if anyone ever orders ribs there.

The first time I came in, a guy in head-to-toe military camouflage was handing out menus. I moved into my house in a snowstorm, in the middle of the night, after a 3,000 mile drive. How wonderful to pull on my boots and my coat (I didn’t even bother buttoning it up) and run across the street, and how unexpected to be greeted by a lantern-jawed guardsman or reservist or whatever he was. But I never saw him again.

The waitresses wear old-fashioned uniforms and opaque support hose. To say the service is bad would sell them short, because actually it approaches Zen-like detachment. They never make eye contact, but they are more languorous than crusty. Ask for a glass of water and see what happens. In a while — maybe five minutes, maybe fifteen — your waitress will casually deposit a half-filled plastic tumbler of warm water at the edge of your table as she drifts past on her way to the counter. For that is her real place: sitting at the counter smoking, or tending to her side-work, or dreaming of a footbath…or five o’clock…or a soft Panamanian moon.

Our waitress hands R. his check and says, "I think I added that up wrong. It's got a one…seven, eight…four…I don't know.” Slaps it face-down in front of him.

One peculiarity of the place is that everyone always gets his or her own individual check. No exceptions.

She puts another check in front of R.’s four-year-old daughter.

So now you have your check. Maybe you’re paying with a twenty and you need to get change for a tip. That means you will have to go through the turnstile, pay the cashier inside the bulletproof booth, and exit the diner. Then, and it is impossible to make this seem intentional, you go back into the diner and leave your tip and go through the turnstile again.

                                           *      *      *

I’m sitting at the Nonsmoking counter absorbed in my newspaper when I become aware of someone standing next to me. I look up. It’s the skinny bug-eyed freak from the parking lot.

“You’re at 1337.” (My street address.) (Momentary panic, followed by acknowledgement.)      

“I used to live there. In the brown room.”

“There’s no brown room in my house.”

“There’s a brown room, and I lived in the brown room.”

A Lebanese family named Thomas owned the house before me. As far as I know, they’d lived there since the Forties. I’d met the surviving members: a 95 year-old woman in a housecoat and her son, of indeterminate age, who occupied the living room on a hospital bed. I try, fruitlessly, to insert the skinny bug-eyed freak into this domestic arrangement. Later, back at home I notice for the first time that some of the bedroom doors have deadbolts.

                                           *      *      *


Crystal Room at the Broad Street Diner, July 6, 2007, photo by Mimi Lipson

In the basement of the diner is the Crystal Room, a function room with a separate entrance. Some of my older neighbors remember when they used to have "gypsy weddings" there. You would hear gunshots, they say. Now it's mostly graduation parties and such: white stretch limos, Mylar balloons, party clothes. The teenagers like to bring the party up to the sidewalk, where they shriek and fight and sing and call to each other from opposite ends of the block. Sometimes they’re at it until 4 AM when the trash truck comes to empty the dumpsters. Between the Crystal Room and the trash truck, it’s hard to sleep with the windows open; but Philadelphia is hot in the summer, and sometimes you can’t avoid it.

Recently, I was awakened in the middle of the night by a bunch of people yelling right outside my house. Then I heard a police car, and then more yelling. But I'm used to the shenanigans by now, and I drifted back to sleep.

In the morning, there was blood splattered all over the sidewalk, and some soiled bandages. My neighbor told me someone had put his fist through the window at the diner. They bandaged him up and tossed him out, and then he had another freakout in front of my door. Sure enough, there it was — and there it remains: a fist-sized hole in the vestibule with a piece of cardboard taped over it.

I could sympathize. Who hasn't had the urge to put their fist through the window at the Broad Street Diner?

The strange thing is, the Broad Street Diner is always busy! Here’s what I’d like to be able to say: that through the doors pass a vibrant and many-hued pageant of humanity. I wish I could tell you about sassy grandmothers and moony-eyed lovers and wise characters in tattered overcoats and fingerless gloves with stuffed parrots on their shoulders. It’s not like that at all. But it does anchor the neighborhood — a neighborhood of working stiffs and church ladies, with a few art students and adventurous yuppies and miscellaneous other outliers mixed in. So I guess it comes down to what your expectations are in terms of local color.

I humbly offer the following:

You enter the diner and turn left past the bulletproof cashier’s cage, past a booth where three old black ladies in church hats are saying grace over their eggs. You sit on a stool by the picture window and order a cup of coffee. The door swings open and in comes a bona fide South Philly alpha female: leather trench coat, stiletto-heeled boots, Tammy Fay makeup. Her perfume overwhelms the room’s ambient septic/antiseptic smell. Her hair, of course, is big big big. She throws herself onto the next stool with a sigh and pulls a cell phone from her comically oversized handbag. A pause. Then she erupts in a maelstrom of activity, holding four simultaneous conversations.

To a waitress walking toward the kitchen with a tray of dirty plates: "Is Jimmy working today? Tell him it's Sandy…Billy's cousin. He knows, he knows."

Into her cell phone: “Hi, honey. Yeah, it’s me. Listen, hon, DO YOU HAVE A TUX? Because it’s BLACK TIE, that’s why. Because it’s the MAYOR. Hang on a sec."

To a waitress behind the counter: “Can you ask Jimmy to make me an egg white omelet? You’re a doll.”

To an old guy who's wandered in selling Eagles swag — he's holding up a jersey for her to inspect: "Let me see the back, hon.” (Makes a twirling motion with the crimson-taloned index finger of her non-phone hand.) “Do you have that in a small in a pink? I need three pink smalls."

To the counter waitress again: "You know what, sweetie? Never mind. Just bring me half a grapefruit and some hot water with lemon."

She goes on like this for maybe ten minutes, the star of the show, seizing the attention of everyone in the diner either actively or passively. Suddenly, she jumps up and rushes through the turnstile and out the vestibule, past the fat, ruddy halfwit to Broad Street, where she flags down a taxi with a wave of her enormous handbag. A ten-dollar bill sits next to her untouched grapefruit.

It’s not Fried Green Tomatoes, but believe me, we’ll look back on it in a few years and wonder what happened to the real America, the place we loved.

                                           *      *      *

EPILOGUE
I probably jinxed the diner. Certainly, I didn’t put my money where my mouth was. I’d be out of coffee, and I’d think of popping in, and then the thought would cause my stomach to make a funny noise. Or I’d have someone over and we’d want to grab a bite, but I couldn’t be bothered with explaining about Hamburger Alley or listening to them complain about the waitresses, so I’d suggest going around the corner for a bowl of pho instead. At some point, I noticed the diner wasn’t open all night anymore. Then it started closing at 9, then 8, and then it became a “breakfast and lunch only” place. Sometimes, though, it was still closed when I walked past at 8:30 or 9 AM. I mentioned it to a neighbor. “Oh, they sold it to some Chinese,” she said, as though this explained everything. One day it didn’t open at all. It’s been closed for over a year now. A handwritten sign, taped to the vestibule window near the fist hole, says, “We Will Grand Opening Soon.”
|
Share This Story

Comments (20)   |   JUMP TO MOST RECENT COMMENT >>

Well said! There used to be a lot of places like this in St Paul, Minnesota, except they were more like supper clubs than diners. There's only one or two of them still in business. A few were torn down. One's a Mexican restaurant now.

There was definitely something surreal about watching them slowly spiral into dereliction and eventual disappearance. Sad, but utterly fascinating.
Nick
03.27.09 at 10:55

Wow I loved this, was transported. It felt like a dreamscape. It is a reminder of the root of why we love design in the first place, the way it resides as a part of the whole. Part of the texture of the larger weaving of life.
Mackenzie
03.27.09 at 10:56

Great essay. I went to high school down the street from the Broad Street Diner. Yes, it was sort of gross and shady, but it was a good place to go when school opened late (but not late enough to make it to the far superior South Street Diner). Though, after a few failed experiments, fries and coffee were the only things I could ever bear to order at the Broad Street Diner, I spent many a morning there. I guess the kids today are stuck going to the McDonalds. Every time I go back to Philly something I loved is gone.
Janna
03.27.09 at 12:47

Mimi - hearty thanks for a sweet trip back to Philly before I have the chance to take a real trip back there this summer :^)

I relished two years of the city while in grad school and absolutely came to rely on a handful of diners for all sorts of respite: a great late-night snack after a project was finished, a good Saturday morning kickstart to get cranking on projects before the next week...

I never made it to the Broad Street, but spent a lot of quality time at the Oak Lane further along Broad and also loved the Trolley Car in Mt. Airy.

Hearty seconds to the thoughts of Mackenzie above - great to see the joys of diner food and the diner served up with a helping of design to boot. Order up!
p.berkbigler
03.27.09 at 01:12

Oops - almost forgot to say: grab some scrapple for me if you make it into town first :^)
p.berkbigler
03.27.09 at 01:14

Steven Starr (of Continental and Morimoto fame) was actually in negotiations to buy The Broad Street Diner until the deal fell through just recently. Too bad, I was quite looking forward to seeing that neighborhood get a bit of life pumped back into it. For a while prior to the summer of '08, I believe it had been converted to some sort of youth nightclub and wasn't being run as a diner at all.

The lack of past tense is this article was confusing! Mimi, when did you write this?
Alex Gilbert
03.27.09 at 05:27

too much nostalgic randomness, not enough design issues. another guest writer fail.

03.27.09 at 05:34

Alex, yes... I wrote it a few years ago & then added the epilogue recently. Not intended as an article as such--I thought of it as creative non-fiction (i.e. all too true).

There was no youth club in the diner--just a heavy rotation of parties in the Crystal Room. That got busted for L&I violations--I think because they were serving liquor. All's been quiet for over a year now.

Starr's people cited "environmental issues" as the deal-breaker, which I thought was an interestingly ambiguous turn of phrase.

Mimi
03.27.09 at 06:15

I am always sad when I see this sort of article. People eat there every day -- or at least, they did. Maybe it's not what you like, but come on, would any of them really like your life?
Joe
03.27.09 at 07:00

i'm pretty sure smoking is no longer allowed in Philly restaurants anymore either
patricia
03.27.09 at 07:15

(*.*)//

Okay, we all hate over-emoticons, but I couldn't help it. I love this story, I'm right there in that diner, and the landscape of inhabiting a bar/diner whatever where there is a crew of eccentric regulars is a song I know and love. Thanks for the story and the flashbacks it induced to diners and denizens long gone
annie
03.28.09 at 01:09

Thanks for the clarifications Mimi. I lived on the 1200 block of Clarion street for a while, but I've been further south since they closed the place.

South Philly is a weird place.
Alex Gilbert
03.28.09 at 01:59

I am still at at loss at to why these pieces keep showing up here. On the other hand, this is such fine writing. Thanks, Mimi.
Brian Hutchins
03.28.09 at 06:37

People internationally read Design Observer daily.

03.30.09 at 01:52

Reminds me of another great slice of diner life, an NPR show available here
24 hours of the Golden Apple Diner, Chicago
Tom
03.30.09 at 06:36

or, rather, here

03.30.09 at 06:38

I was surprised to see this article, being that I haven't been to this blog in a while. Despite this article seeming random, I think there's a lack of imagination on the part of some of the readers. The Broad Street Diner is a landmark, and is so because of it aesthetic qualities along with the experience. The bottom line is, it creates a memorable experience that can be positive or negative. Isn't the same true of design?

I also believe the Observer has something here that a lot of other blogs aren't doing; that is they are broadening the scope of their subject matter while adding more content that isn't merely visual. The writing on this blog has always separated it from the other blogs out there that simply show a lot of pretty pictures or nice design.
samantha
03.30.09 at 02:14

I remember this place....

I cannot say that I look back on the three years I lived in south philly with such nostalgia. I winessed a murder infront of the beer distributor on Snyder, was mugged...twice, and suffered a demonic landlord.

But, the shining light was Melrose diner, just a bit further down broad street on snyder... That place atleast had a modicum of class and a real, post church service feel.
shane johnston
04.01.09 at 02:24

thank you for the flashback.
When I attended Tyler School of Art--all the way at the north end of Broad Street--there was this incredibly looooong commute into Center City Philadelphia. The Broad Street Diner as the changeover to the Broad St. subway, I believe...or it's where one had to wait for the endless bus down Broad Street...or something like that. And in 1972, when I was there, it looked just like that. Oak Lane...think there was a pharmacy there too.
joy
04.04.09 at 05:26

Great piece that manages to capture the essence of both the diner experience and Philly. Love the part with the South Philly alpha female.
Nida S
04.10.09 at 01:08


Design Observer encourages comments to be short and to the point; as a general rule, they should not run longer than the original post. Comments should show a courteous regard for the presence of other voices in the discussion. We reserve the right to edit or delete comments that do not adhere to this standard.
Read Complete Comments Policy >>


Name             

Email address 




Please type the text shown in the graphic.


|
Share This Story



ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Mimi Lipson is a writer and artist living in Kingston, NY but dreaming of Philadelphia. Her stained glass can be seen at mimilipson.com. Her writing has appeared in Chronogram and will appear in Yeti.
More Bio >>

DESIGN OBSERVER JOBS









RELATED POSTS


The Filmic Page: Chris Marker's Commentaires
The French director Chris Marker’s book Commentaires is as innovative as book design as his documentaries are as films.

Not Afraid of Noise: Mexico City Stories
A photographic tour of Mexico City, house by house, wall by wall.

From the Archive: Surface Wreckage
Why do photographs and images of torn street posters exert such a powerful hold on the imagination and emotions?

Premature Demolition
The Folk Art Museum, David Adjaye's market hall, and the first addition to the Morgan Library. If three makes a trend, then premature demolition qualifies.

Hale County Revisited
An in-depth look at Hale County, Alabama, an accidental social-design laboratory.